Dear Dedicated Members for Change,

In Nineteenth Century and early Twentieth Century America our grandfathers and great-grandfathers socialized primarily through fraternal orders and clubs.   (To a degree this also applied to our grandmothers and great-grandmothers, but they were often excluded in those days and had to form their own fraternities and clubs, separated from the men by gender.)

Clubs and fraternal orders often had great similarities, but there were also a big differences in that fraternities had rituals, regalia, and secrets.   Clubs typically didn't have those trappings.   Clubs were often centered around charitable, business, professional, or agricultural matters.  And some of the early clubs - like Rotary, Jaycees. and Kiwanis - still exist and flourish today.   This article, however, will focus on fraternal orders.

In the 1800's and early 1900's the list of fraternal orders in North America numbered in the thousands.  Most of them were localized in a city, or a region or a state.   A few were national, or even professed to be international.   Membership in individual fraternities was huge - tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, even millions of members.  Some of the bigger ones were the Freemasons, the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, the Elks, the Moose, the Knights of Pythias, the Redmen.  Most of the fraternal orders have faded away - becoming historical footnotes.   Even some of the largest orders have diminished to a handful of Lodges and a few hundred members.   All of them had fraternal buildings (variously called "halls", "lodges", or "temples"), typically located in the center of town.   Most were constructed so that the ground floor could be dedicated to commercial uses (thus providing rents and a flow of income to the fraternity) with the second floor (and occasionally a third floor) dedicated to the fraternal meetings and gatherings.   But, the hard truth is that the landscape of America is littered with the skeletons of old fraternal halls that no longer host a fraternity.  

In the heyday of fraternities, the Lodges were gathering places for members who could come together to eat and drink, hold meetings following strict scripts, pay homage to a higher power, emphasize watchwords such as loyalty, truth, fellowship, friendship, justice, love, and a dozen other expressions that formed the basis for their particular fraternal teachings.   Much like going to church every week, members attended fraternal meetings on a regular basis to renew their connections and discuss good works.   And in the early days - when there were precious few government programs or services - fraternities provided solace (and even financial help) to members and their families who had lost their jobs, or were sick or in distress, or had lost a family member - they were true beneficial societies which paid financial benefits to members who had fallen on hard times or needed some help.   In the early days, fraternities ran orphanages for children of deceased members, homes for elderly members and widows, even hospitals for members who were ill, and cemeteries for members who died.   Many fraternal orders developed military branches which enticed men who had served during America's numerous wars and armed conflicts.  

There was a time in the history of North America when fraternal membership numbers were exploding upwards.   The number of Lodges, and the number of members, grew dramatically at the end of the 1800's and the early decades of the 1900's - often called "The Golden Age of Fraternalism."  At its peak, it is estimated that some 40% of adult men in America held membership in at least one fraternal order.    And then, in the span of just a few decades, all fraternities experienced a decline in the number of Lodges and a diminution in membership.   In many fraternal orders, the drop was precipitous and in some the decline was fatal. 

The reason for the decline is not a mystery.  

Society changed and fraternal orders did not.   At first, the societal changes were slow, and then they became precipitous.   The changes were everywhere - transportation, information, food, clothing, language, entertainment, technology.   Society got a lot faster - moving from the barn dances, to the sock hops, to the raves.   The wearing of tuxedos and long gowns was common in the early years of fraternal orders, but rare in today's society - yet many fraternal orders insist that members wear tuxedos and gowns at certain gatherings.   One can only imagine that in the days before radio, movies and television, the acting out of degree work in costume was an enjoyable interlude for fraternal members.   But in today's world, it doesn't translate as well.   Reading, verbatim, passages (using stilted language from a prior century) is not going to bring (or keep) young members in the fraternity.  

Perhaps the prime examples of the fraternal resistance to change is the fact that many Lodges still use hand-written minutes which are read verbatim at meetings, while eschewing electronic recorded minutes which can be delivered via email.   Potential members born in the age of computers look upon such things as quirky at best.   Those born in 2001 are now 23 years of age; those born in 1991 are now 33 years of age.  If we are going to attract new blood and the next generation of members into our Lodges we need to understand that Frank Sinatra and Ethel Merman are world's apart from Drake and Taylor Swift.

F - L - T

Dave Rosenberg
Past Grand Master
Jurisdiction of California