Dear Dedicated Members for Change,
There is a famous quotation that is generally attributed to the world-renown genius Albert Einstein: "Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." Historically, Einstein may or may not have said these words, but this urban legend persists. However, that's not the point of this article. Whether the words were uttered by Albert Einstein or Alfred E. Neuman, they state an important truth.
Do these words have any meaning for Odd Fellowship? Yes, they surely do.
Odd Fellowship is an ancient fraternal order tracing its history to the early 19th Century in North America. Over the subsequent decades, Odd Fellowship expanded and blossomed like a fraternal wildfire across the continent. Lodges sprang up in virtually every state and province. The early Odd Fellows were excited to be part of bringing a new fraternity to life. That excitement translated into hard work contributing funds to start the fraternity, building the Lodge Hall, accumulating furnishings and regalia, and bringing new members into the front door. Membership numbers exploded and at one point reached one million. In the beginning, the growth was just focused on Odd Fellows Lodges, but the Order soon added Encampments, Rebekah Lodges, youth Lodges, and a military component. And then, the exponential growth ground to a halt in the 20th Century, and the decline continues into the 21st Century. Membership numbers have generally declined, Lodges have faded away, and some units of our Order have disappeared. The early excitement has faded.
The reason is not hard to understand. Our Order has diminished because we have failed to adapt as society has changed.
Change is both a human and a natural phenomenon. Everything evolves and changes over time. In the human realm, think of clothing, travel, entertainment, marketing, food, etc. We don't ride horses to work anymore and we don't gather around the radio in the evening to hear the news.
Yet, change in Odd Fellowship is rare, and very hard to achieve. There is great resistance to change in our Order. I am convinced that the leaders of our Order at the Sovereign Grand Lodge level absolutely want our Order's membership to grow, but they resist the very changes which will enable that growth. I imagine they believe that if we just get better at running meetings reading our ritual, we will dramatically increase our membership.
How has that been going for the past 50 years?
We have to remember that because human life expectancy has increased, we live with six generations at any given time: the so-called Silent Generation (1925-1945), Baby Boomers (1946-1964), Generation X (1965-1979), Millennials (1980-1994), Generation Z (1995-2012), and Generation Alpha (2013-present). A member of Gen Z may never have heard of Groucho Marx, and a member of the Silent Generation has likely no idea of who Billie Eilish is.
And until the members of the Silent Generation and the Baby Boomer Generation (who essentially control Odd Fellowship today at the highest levels) heed Einstein's admonition and appreciate what it takes to bring in new members from the newer generations, we will, sadly, continue to diminish as an Order.
F - L - T
Dave Rosenberg
Past Grand Master
Jurisdiction of California


